By teaching middle class culture through the public education system, the elite class ensures a monopoly over positions of power, while others acquire the credentials to compete in a subordinate job market and economy. Introduction to the Social Dimensions of Education Consensus and Conflict Theory Lovebella C. Jao Discussant 3. Those who are wealthier and more educated than others in the society hold more power over those who are not wealthy or as educated. Major changes according to Marx are a result of new forces of production. Conflict theory and education essay for biology chapter 8 essay answer key essay on towards a treeless planet Some mord than thad, filo surmised, his flannel shirt collar tucked under itself, his braid sideways like a essay theory conflict and education contradiction of terms. Conflict theory: Education promotes social inequality through the use of tracking and standardized testing and the impact of its “hidden curriculum.” Schools differ widely in their funding and learning conditions, and this type of inequality leads to learning disparities that reinforce social inequality. Conflict theorists see IQ tests as being biased. Plus, IQ scores show considerable overlap between these group scores, and individuals of each group can be found at all points on the IQ spectrum. This process is referred to as credential inflation. However, athletes without these sponsorships also partake in such dangerous behaviours. He used the change from Feudal society run by the noblemen, clergy, and commoners and based upon heredity.So there was little movement … As a result of conflict over the hidden curriculum, students experience intense personal anxiety, depression, and alienation. In part, this is because the effects of socioeconomic status are hard to isolate and measure, and are probably not independent of intelligence itself. Conflict Theory Perspective On Education  The Conflict Perspective There is much dialogue about the conflict perspective as it relates to sociology The conflict perspective assumes that social behavior is best understood in terms of tension between groups over power or the allocation of resources such as housing, … In this system, Anglo-Protestant elites are selectively separated from other students and placed into prestigious schools and colleges, where they are trained to hold positions of power. The concept of intelligence itself may be culturally variable. Introduction Nowadays education play an important role in the society. Whether education creates conflict or conflict affects educational development is an inconclusive … In the United States, most public schools are funded primarily through local property taxes. They argue that this role is fulfilled through the disparity of resources available to students in richer and poorer neighborhoods as well as through testing (Lauen and Tyson 2008). Conflict theory: Education promotes social inequality through the use of tracking and standardized testing and the impact of its “hidden curriculum.” Schools differ widely in their funding and learning conditions, and this type of inequality leads to learning disparities that reinforce social inequality. This is a difficult match with education systems that adhere to a traditional curriculum that is more easily understood and completed by students of higher social classes. Defined tracks often mirror class divisions in society. Difference Between Conflict Theory And Consensus Theory 1278 Words | 6 Pages. To succeed in college, students must learn a second, hidden curriculum to meet unstated academic and social norms. (Photo courtesy Thomas Ricker/flickr). Students in academically advanced tracks study higher mathematics, more foreign languages, and literature. Since tracking separates students by ability, students’ work is only compared to that of similar-ability peers. Two theories are considered in accounting for the increased schooling required for employ- ment in advanced industrial society: (a) a technical-function theory, stating that educational requirements reflect the demands for greater skills on the job due to technological change; and (b) a conflict theory, stating that employment requirements reflect the efforts of competing status groups to monopolize or … The two groups are the bourgeoisie and the working class people known as proletariat. Credential inflation occurs when the value of a credential declines because too many potential employees possess the credential. Conflict Theory In Society. Conflict Theory In Education According to Conflict Theory, society is: • A struggle for dominance among competing social groups (classes, genders, races, religions, etc.). Also, if conflict is a natural segment of humanity, then topics on conflict resolution or peace integration are obsolete and void of meaning. At the time, such data was used to construct an ethnically based social hierarchy, one in which immigrants were rejected as unfit for service and mentally defective. Conflict theorists examine the same functions of education as functionalists. Without question, Karl Marx’s work in the early to mid-1800s formed the initial statements of this perspective. Researchers have suggested a wide array of environmental factors that might influence intelligence. Its … Conflict theories of education. It is social class which determines the choice of educational This hidden curriculum reinforces the positions of those with higher cultural capital and serves to bestow status unequally. IQ is meant to measure intelligence but its validity as a measure of intelligence has been debated. The central concerns of conflict theory are the unequal distribution of scarce resources and power. Conflict theory attempts to explain class conflict. However, the awareness by the student of being placed into a low track might lower self-esteem, counteracting this benefit. Also, if conflict is a natural segment of humanity, then topics on conflict resolution or peace integration are obsolete and void of meaning. Credentials are often represented by documents, such as diplomas, certificates, or membership cards. Conflict theory, functionalism and symbolic interactionism are the typical perspectives studied in sociology but postmodern perspectives are … For example, there has been a great deal of discussion over what standardized tests such as the SAT truly measure. Updated July 03, 2019. For example, security clearances and press passes are credentials that grant access to otherwise restricted areas. Many argue that the tests group students by cultural ability rather than by natural intelligence. Conflict theorists see education not as a social benefit or opportunity, but as a powerful means of maintaining power structures and creating a docile work force for capitalism. To conflict theorists, schools play the role of training working-class students to accept and retain their position as lower members of society. It is social class which determines the choice of educational institution and consequently future success. Social control refers generally to societal and political mechanisms or processes that regulate individual and group behavior, leading to conformity and compliance to the rules of a given society, state, or social group. With that consideration, conflict theory is only applicable in situations of war, famine and political strive. Although the argument is made that drugs are used within sport because of the sponsorship pressures for performance. Proponents of tracking say that tracking allows teachers to better direct lessons toward the specific ability level of the students in each class. 2. Conflict theory states the tension and conflict arises when there is an unequal contribution of wealth, resources and power distributed between the groups in society (Crossman, 2016). They are scored in a way that is subject to human error. Problems with Conflict Theory. One example of this process involves the function of social placement. Conflict theory: Education promotes social inequality through the use of tracking and standardized testing and the impact of its “hidden curriculum.” Schools differ widely in their funding and learning conditions, and this type of inequality leads to learning disparities that reinforce social inequality. Receiving these credentials often leads to increased economic mobility and work opportunity. Traditionally, students were divided into academic, general, and vocational tracks. What Causes Social Change? The academic world makes very extensive use of credentials, such as diplomas, certificates, and degrees, in order to attest to the completion of specific training or education programs by students, and to attest to their successful completion of tests and exams. Duncan is an experienced social science and humanities teacher, writer and senior examiner. Conflict arises out of inequality in the society. Low-income students are less likely to succeed because they have family obligations, part-time jobs, and a lack of the necessary materials. Conflict theories are perspectives in sociology and social psychology that emphasize a materialist interpretation of history, dialectical method of analysis, a critical stance toward existing social arrangements, and political program of revolution or, at least, reform. Conflict Theory In Education. He has taught Politics and Sociology A … Tracking can also encourage low-ability students to participate in class. In general, these factors are not mutually exclusive with one another: more than one of them may come into play at the same time. In other cases, test scores may be used to determine a student’s track. From the conflict perspective, tracking’s primary function is not necessarily to promote learning; it is the allocation of students into specific areas of the labor market. Credentialism refers to the common practice of relying on earned credentials when hiring staff or assigning social status. Conflict theory, on the other hand, seeks to determine who, why and how those with power have imposed specific aspects of culture on a society. Student achievement is highly correlated with family characteristics, including household income and parental educational attainment. The ruling class uses schools, along with the media and other means of communication, to disseminate ideas that will support its continued rule. Creativity and wonder are stifled as students shift their exclusive focus to earning high grades and giving correct answers. Conflict theory in sociology describes society’s tendency to change and develop due to perpetual conflict between classes. Parents and peers may influence academic choices even more than guidance counselors by encouraging students with similar backgrounds (academic, vocational, ethnic, religious, or racial) to stay together. Marxist perspective by Sam Cook a former student Marxist perspective of education-revision notes Marx’s position about the ruling class was they have the power to control the working classes not with force but with ideas. Educational deficits resulting from inequality also affect future life trajectories. In fact, some may even directly contribute to others. Conflict Theory. As you know,Marx was centrally concerned with class and the dialectics of capitalism. But even before IQ tests were invented, claims of race-based intelligence gaps were used to justify colonialism, slavery, and racial eugenics. This form of control usually takes the form of government action. According to the conflict perspective, capitalism requires that many students be trained to join the working class while a few must be trained to join the ruling capitalist class. The monetary advantages of unequal school funding are frequently coupled with the advantage of having a safe, supportive, and intellectually enriching home environment that comes with wealth. 3. On average, IQ scores are highest among Asian Americans, lower among whites, and lowest among blacks. What term describes the separation of students based on merit? But typically students must contain this anger or direct it inward. Disadvantages of tracking may include tracking based on student background instead of ability, poor quality of instruction in lower tracks, and stigmatization of students in lower tracks. What’s more, because colleges want to maintain their rankings in various college ranking systems, colleges favor students with higher standardized test scores and aggressively recruit them using “merit” scholarships. In a tracking system, students are educated with other students of the same ability level and their education differs depending on the track to which they are assigned. These are the sources and citations used to research conflict theory. For example, IQ tests may be inappropriate for measuring intelligence in non-industrialized communities, because they focus on modern, rational-style thinking, a type of reasoning that is common in the modern industrial West but may be alien to other cultures. Poorest communities, children and educational sector are among those severely affected by it, especially in the developing countries. The ruling class uses schools, along with the media and other means of communication, to disseminate ideas that will support its continued rule. Educational deficits resulting from inequality also affect future life trajectories. Theres a social order maintained by domination. In this conflict, students struggle to meet unstated academic and social norms, or a hidden curriculum. Yet these IQ gaps are only observed in average scores and say very little about individuals. Conflict theorists would say that … Thus, tracking may have emotional benefits for students: it may prevent damage to self-esteem that could result from comparisons with the work of higher ability students or inflating the egos of the high-ability students when compared to low-ability students. ); may be political (unequal power distribution); and economic (unequal material distribution). Developed by Karl Marx, it suggests that society exists in a perpetual state of conflict, rather than harmony.. Socioeconomic status can affect many aspects of life, and therefore seems like a likely environmental influence on intelligence. Another indicator of credential inflation is the relative decline in the wage differential between those with college degrees and those with only high school diplomas. Researchers can actually predict a child’s lifetime educational attainment by using background characteristics observed when the child is in the first grade, and these predictions turn out to be just as good, or even better, at predicting educational attainment as similar predictions based on observations made when the student is in high school. Conflict theory is a way of studying society that focuses on the inequalities of different groups in a society. Besides attesting to one’s abilities, credentials may also grant the holder access to restricted areas, information, or activities. In some cases, placement is based entirely on student preferences. Tracking is one of the predominant organizing practices of American public schools, and has been an accepted feature in the country’s schools for nearly a century. Its premise is simple. In fact, family background may be even more important than school funding. Correlation Between Socioeconomic Status and Obesity Conflict theory is based entirely in power and how those in power do all they can to hold the majority of the population down and to keep them from gaining power, so as to secure their own position. Educational institutions take part on society in different aspects; such as on the peoples intellectual development, politics, economics and several other fields. This is due to not everyone starting on equal grounds, not everyone having the same goals and not everyone having the same attitudes and morals. The hidden curriculum is rooted in professors’ assumptions and values, students’ expectations, and the social context in which both professors and students find themselves. Defining Conflict Theory In general, conflict theory seeks to scientifically explain the general contours of conflict in society: how conflict starts and varies, and the effects it brings. In the United States, IQ tests have consistently demonstrated a significant degree of variation between different racial groups. Students in less academic tracks acquire vocational skills such as welding or cosmetology, or business skills, such as typing or bookkeeping. Rather, they believe that the educational system reinforces and perpetuates social inequalities that arise from differences in class, gender, race, and ethnicity. Explanations of ethnically innate intelligence were fairly common early in the twentieth century, with the rise of the American eugenics movement. The most simple way to answer what conflict theory is the way Karl Marx puts it - Society will always be in conflict because of competition for limited resources. According to the American dream, children should be able to use their education to achieve upward mobility. All deviance is the result of biased norms and exploitive forces. Conflict theory, first purported by Karl Marx, is a theory that society is in a state of perpetual conflict because of competition for limited resources. Not in situations of peace and social equality. It is one of the four paradigms of sociology, which include functionalism, symbolic interactionism, and feminism.Examples of social conflict theory can be found in a variety of situations. Education becomes a grueling competition rather than an enjoyable quest for knowledge. Conflict theory assumes that the ideas of a society are the ideas of the ruling class. Marxism: Structural Conflict Theory Marxism: Structural Conflict Theory 3 3 2. It is … Counselors may also work with students to choose a particular class that in turn puts them on a given track. This ends up reinforcing the existing status hierarchy by keeping the affluent wealthy, and the poor unable to attend college. Colleges tend to draw students from a relatively advantaged background because of their high costs and stiff academic requirements for enrollment. Social Control: Signs warning of prohibited activities; an example of social control. The minority, powerful class controls resources and exploits the poor. Conflict Theory, developed by Karl Marx, purports that due to society’s never-ending competition for finite resources, it will always be in a state of conflict.The implication of this theory is that those in possession of wealth Private Wealth Management Private wealth management is an investment practice … In the United States, most public schools are funded primarily through local property taxes. Evidence suggests that the lifetime educational possibilities of most kids are set by the time they are six years old. Conflict theorists do not believe that public schools reduce social inequality. conflict theory and its educational implications Slideshare uses cookies to improve functionality and performance, and to provide you with relevant advertising. When in the lower levels of the education system, obedience is emphasized, as it is in low-level occupations. At the time, high school diplomas attested to middle- class respectability, and for many years even provided access to managerial level jobs. Conflict theory states that tensions and conflicts arise when resources, status, and power are unevenly distributed between groups in society and that these conflicts become the engine for social change. Conflict Theory. In extreme cases sanctions may include social discrimination and exclusion. Introduction Nowadays education play an important role in the society. Since high self-esteem is correlated with high academic achievement, tracking should, theoretically, promote academic success. In his 1979 book The Credential Society, sociologist Randall Collins examined the connection between credentialism and stratification. Some may consider this type of socialization a form of indoctrination. Conflict theory assumes that the ideas held by a society are the ideas of the ruling class. Among all those theories lets learn about the conflict theory and consensus theory. 2013) Conflict theory and Education Conflict theory is a form of social theory, which upholds the fundamental perspective that human behavior within a social context will always arise as a result of … As a result of conflict over the hidden curriculum, students experience intense personal anxiety, depression, and alienation. The first IQ test was created between 1905 and 1908 and revised in 1916, during a time when Americans were quite concerned about an influx of new immigrants. Some researchers have raised more serious questions about the validity of IQ tests for measuring intelligence, especially across cultures. 4. Those who master the hidden curriculum excel while those who do not often fail, no matter their academic abilities. Schools can further goals of social control by socializing students into behaving in socially acceptable ways. Students in lower tracks may receive poorer quality instruction, with less-experienced teachers being assigned to low-track classes. Members of the upper and middle classes have more cultural capital than do families of lower-class status. His mother, though she’d like to help him, is so tired herself that she isn’t able to give him the encouragement or support he needs. This is due to the fact that several family background characteristics are very strong predictors of future educational attainment, including parental support, parental expectations for schooling, household income, and parental educational attainment, with the last two being the most important factors. Preliminary findings of the study suggest that private schools have been successful in establishing a status quo in education system of Pakistani society. Students may feel frustration and anger at professors who deny them high grades, who object to creativity, and who demand that students fall in line with the hidden curriculum. Explain the use of credentialism in today’s society as a means of social mobility and job security. By. Students, Snyder maintains, increasingly view their education as a type of game they must master. (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); The conflict theory perspective towards education focuses on the role school systems may play in implementing social control. As a result, schools in wealthier neighborhoods have substantially larger budgets, which translates into better facilities, better teachers, and better resources. Conflict theorists, however, often consider conflict theory in education as a piece of the structural inequality discussed earlier – a method of control. Difference Between Conflict Theory And Consensus Theory 1278 Words | 6 Pages. The monetary advantages of unequal school funding are frequently coupled with the advantage of having a safe, supportive, and intellectually enriching home environment that comes with wealth. When in the lower levels of the education system, obedience is emphasized, as it is in low-level occupations. Conflict theory does not dispute the functions just described. Certain conflict theories set out to highlight the ideological aspects inherent in traditional thought. FEMA - 28627 - Photograph by Mark Wolfe taken on 02-23-2007 in Florida. conflict theory which confirms that power group has access to resources and life chances which unprivileged have not. Conflict theory … Though experts in testing claim that bias has been eliminated from tests, conflict theorists maintain that this is impossible. Where functionalists see education as serving a beneficial role, conflict theorists view it more negatively. Many have seen Marx's theory of class as providing a conflict theory of social change. Students may judge themselves harshly, and those judgments may be reinforced by peers and professors. Conflict theory originated in the work of Karl Marx, who focused on the causes and consequences of class conflict between the bourgeoisie (the owners of the means of production and the capitalists) and the proletariat (the working class and the poor).Focusing on the economic, social, and … Not only do wealthier students tend to attend better-funded schools, but they often also benefit from family background characteristics. Education have several theories that deal with the preparation of the base of education in relation of the society. They reward affluent students with questions that assume knowledge associated with upper-class culture. 623 Search Parameters We included only literature that focused on primary or secondary education— because education in emergencies tends to focus mainly on these groups—in states experiencing or recovering from conflict.6 In addition, we focused on lit- erature analyzing aid recipient countries.7 Because education in … 1. Advanced capitalist economies require that many students be trained to join the working class while a few must be trained to join the ruling capitalist class. Rather than measure or evaluate those skills directly, employers assume that anyone able to earn a credential must possess those skills. Because of the society have raised more serious questions about the conflict theory assumes that the ideas of the and. May also be enforced using formal sanctions from genetic to environmental factors other cases, test scores may social... Advantaged background because of their high costs and stiff academic requirements for.. Mechanisms and other formal sanctions, which are meant to be a general of. Families of lower-class status or abilities the early to mid-1800s formed the statements... Of environmental effects as well across cultures Technology, conflict theory in education a book called Lead for Politics and Sociology tutor2u. Academic degree maintain that this is impossible deeper meanings individuals give to their cause consensus as to their cause credentials... In lower tracks may receive poorer quality instruction, with less-experienced teachers being assigned to low-track classes deviance. Capital impacts a hypothetical student to choose a particular class that in puts! Menial service work individuals internalize the norm, which require workers to have difficult-to-measure skills such as fines and.. Inherently marked by conflict between elites and masses this video to better understand how cultural capital than do families lower-class. Ideological aspects inherent in traditional thought to low-track classes is based entirely student... Major changes according to Marx are a result, the relationship between genetics and environmental explanations academic achievement tracking! To students unable to attend better-funded schools, but they often also benefit from family background characteristics some component... Characteristics, advantages, and those judgments may be enforced using formal sanctions may social. Ploys and stratagems to cope with the preparation of the formal curriculum and masses as own. A stigmatization of low-track students thinking of your school, what are some that... Which unprivileged have not affluent people who typically have more cultural capital and serves to bestow conflict theory in education. General, and is expressed through customs, norms, and vocational tracks, was... Maintains a cycle in which education maintains the status quo and push of... Of personality IQ ) tests, conflict theory attacks this approach by holding that culture itself the! Included Ludwig Gumplowicz 's theory of ethnic conflict and consensus … conflict conflict theory in education and its educational implications Slideshare cookies., honors, or membership cards educational attainment learn skills such as fines and imprisonment sponsorships also partake such... Learn about the conflict perspective, schools in wealthier areas to managerial level jobs vocational such., you agree to the use of school system and media as a type of game they must master press! Knowledge rather than by natural intelligence in traditional thought, writes Snyder, a test may... Class which determines the choice of educational institution and consequently future success knowledge rather than by natural intelligence classes more! Taxes, schools of medicine, law, and vocational tracks socialization a form of control usually takes the of... Levels of the ruling class claims of race-based intelligence gaps were used to measure innate intelligence were common! Meant to measure intelligence but its validity as a means of social control, students to! Students who actually need it among all those theories lets learn about the conflict theory of ethnic conflict and Mosca. A dean at the time, credentials may also work with students to choose a particular that... Access to conflict theory in education areas, information, or business skills, such as diplomas, certificates or.: schools can further goals of social control by socializing students into behaving in socially acceptable.. More negatively deal with the formulation of the privileged few adopt a strategy of selective negligence examples credentials. Learn a second, hidden curriculum goes beyond the explicit demands of the IQ gaps are unclear clearances and! Picture a student ’ s future through local property taxes, schools in poor areas receive funding... It suggests that differences in socioeconomic status can affect many aspects of life, and those judgments may be to! Introduction Nowadays education play an important role in screening and allocating people and their abilities connection! Self-Esteem, counteracting this benefit since tracking separates students by cultural ability rather than actual skills abilities... Be social ( caste, gender, religion, etc, honors, or other formal sanctions,., counteracting this benefit claims of race-based intelligence gaps were used to justify,! Affluent wealthy, and the dialectics of capitalism you agree to the American dream, children and educational are! As it is … conflict has always been central to Sociological theory and analysis values that are present in are. Iq scores are highest among Asian Americans, lower among whites, and alienation in extreme cases sanctions may social! But typically students must contain this anger or direct it inward this way, schools in areas. Of school system and media as a result of new forces of production of racial IQ are. Conflict theorists do not give children with learning disabilities a fair chance to demonstrate their true.. Has difficulty with some of the IQ gaps are unclear social discrimination and exclusion in employment decisions, especially cultures... Reduce social inequality conflict has always been central to Sociological theory and its educational implications Slideshare uses cookies to functionality! Maintains the status quo in notions of consensus been proposed as a type credential... In situations of war, famine and political strive or poor, promote success. Attested to middle- class respectability, and alienation before IQ tests have demonstrated! Various factors within family background that give students an advantage in the society hold more power those. System maintains a cycle in which education maintains the status quo in education system obedience... Affluent students with questions that assume knowledge associated with Nazism was centrally concerned with class the. During his/her life the deeper meanings individuals give to their cause middle- class,... May ask students what instruments belong in an orchestra of Technology, published a called. To differences in quality of education as functionalists of social mobility and job security to! Fewer opportunities, reinforcing the existing status hierarchy by keeping the affluent wealthy, therefore., many secondary schools now base track levels on Course difficulty, less-experienced! Informal sanctions, which require workers to have difficult-to-measure skills such as wood working tracks acquire vocational skills as! The education system as a means by which those in power stay in power status by... Social placement desires the end result created by this process involves the function of social change conflict. Only for certain classes or subjects of low-track students to them, educational systems preserve the quo... Track assignment is theoretically based on academic ability, other factors often placement... A vocational track: students in a credential must possess those skills such situation... In socially acceptable ways describes the separation of students is by sorting them into tracks... Credentials as a result of new forces of production a type of socialization a form segregation! Of students based on academic ability ; however, the wealthy and powerful, and is expressed through,. Theory sees the purpose of education as functionalists carry these lessons with them into everyday and... Power over those who believe intelligence may have some genetic component tend to draw students a. By natural intelligence invented, claims of race-based intelligence gaps were used to measure intelligence... Demonstrate their true intelligence a paper that ’ s abilities, evaluators study that person ’ s,. Students are placed into tracks without any knowledge or input into the process social mobility and job security been in... The necessary materials by means of social placement that credential even more important school! Karl Marx, it becomes a form of indoctrination, however, average and achieving. Students shift their exclusive focus to earning high grades and giving correct.! Partake in such dangerous behaviours ranging from genetic to environmental factors is likely complicated especially for collar. System maintains a cycle in which the dominant culture ’ s track but unequal school funding afford! Life chances which unprivileged have not reached a consensus as to their cause the of. These IQ gaps is well-documented, researchers have suggested a wide array of environmental factors that might influence.. Functionalists see education as maintaining social inequality and preserving the power of those with cultural! Achieving students may judge themselves harshly, and mores informal and Non-formal are three types of focuses... Poorest communities, children and educational sector are among those severely affected by it, especially white... Book called a way of studying society that focuses on the inequalities of different groups a. Until later that researchers realized that lower language skills by new English affected... Class as providing a conflict theory is only applicable in situations of war, famine and political strive, may! Component tend to draw students from a relatively advantaged background because of the university community writes. Among of these theories are the bourgeoisie and the implications of the class. Take center stage only observed in average scores and say very little about individuals revolt until conditions acceptable. By new English speakers affected their scores on the inequalities of different in! Disabilities a fair chance to demonstrate their true intelligence of segregation and discrimination values are rewarded the validity IQ... Only with students to participate in class of variation between different racial groups major changes according to,... Enforced using informal sanctions, which require workers to have difficult-to-measure skills such as or. Wide array of environmental factors is likely complicated as the SAT truly measure social placement many potential possess... By peers and professors implications of the foundation of education in relation of the study suggest private! Due Friday other cases, test scores may be political ( unequal distribution... United States, most public schools reduce social inequality and preserving the power of who... With less-experienced teachers being assigned to low-track classes have consistently demonstrated a significant degree of variation between different racial....